Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Samuel Goldman's avatar

He dis not consider himself Jewish; Jewish tradition has religion being passed from the maternal side

Why should we make a claim from left field that has no validity other than some whimsy which is unrelated to reality

Expand full comment
David Armstrong's avatar

I suppose the question is: "Is being Jewish more like being Catholic or Muslim, or is it more like being Irish, Greek, Italian, Egyptian, or Chinese?" Any and all of those cultural identities can include individuals who subscribe to any religion or none. Is it, therefore, possible to be a Jewish-Baptist or a Jewish-Atheist.? Not being Jewish, I am not qualified to answer those questions.

Expand full comment
3 more comments...

No posts